I visited the Pink Pony on 1012/18 and loved it! We went around 6 so it was pretty busy but we got a seat right and the bar and had dinner and drinks there (the rum runners are great) I also enjoyed my french dip sandwich and my husband got whitefish tacos both were great. Our bartender was great he made good conversation with us. We also stopped in the store the guy and girl working were very friendly and helpful it had so many cute things. The hotel lobby also looked very nice next time we visit the island we plan to stay there.